Alas as so do others ala barnett, joey johns or have you forgot that / them? The fact is clear for all to see was carvell looked and raised the forearm, and as a former player I know this is unforgiveable. Look forward to the RFL explaining there decisions to the family of a seriously hurt / career ending player one day. Irony by your flippancy on the subject, i think not :SHOOT

Must have been a different video to the one I saw,I was sure he cuffed him on the head and from the side!

The video evidence clearly shows the initial contact on Sherwins upper torso the bouncing up to head height. This isn't a high tackle and is something that happens in lots of tackles at all levels of rugby.

If Fielden does exactly the same thing to Briers tomorrow my response will be the same. I'm certainly not a biased fan and don't let emotions get in the way of clear thinking.

If it isn't a high tackle by the rules of the game then why are players penalised for doing the same thing in a lot of the high tackles you see now then?