Another Win

Quote: charlie caroli "Faxcar , where did I say it was a bad shout ?I asked what Murrell was best in the League at ?I presume by your Answer , you think he is the best 6 or 13 ?As for your question about who offers more ?Yes I think Martin Ridyard would be more valuable to a team , when Murrell has scored as many points as Martin then you can compare them , as well as Tactical Kicking , and linking the Backs and Forwards , just look and compare Fax points for , and Fax points against to Leighs , we have scored most points , most tries , have the Leagues best defence , and ARE 10 points clear at the TOP , I think that gives you a clue somewhere .

While I agree Fax are the form team at the moment , as you have won around 5 on the trot , but 5 is not 17 is it ?Charlie knows
I think Murrell offers as much overall, as any player in the Fax team which is all I can comment on from what I have actually seen on a regular basis.

Do I know anything? No compared to you Charlie I clearly don't know anything but then I'm not on my own as you keep telling us, but I would rather be ignorant than arrogant, even tongue in cheek.

However I knew that from your point of view the best overall player must be playing for Leigh.

Martin Ridyard is without doubt a quality player and this year with the team Leigh have he has looked even better but is he any better than Murrell?

If we could do a club swap Murrell for Ridyard keeping the rest of the teams the same we would find out.

For all the stats you have quoted about how well Leigh are doing this year it's not down to one individual like you seem to be saying about Ridyard, after all, how long has he been there, seems a long time to finally get them moving, what has he been waiting for.