Yes, it is subjective, and he does have the occasional bad game. There was one game last year (and I just cant remember which one it was - someone will tell me) where the opposition peppered Rob with the high bomb time after time, and after he caught every single one, ran them back and even scored from one they gave up that particular idea!!

Yes, I would have him in my team and the season will tell, he will do more good for us than bad.

Was a disappointing game last night. First half went well but the second half was a disaster.

Was very simple why we lost... too many penalties. No matter who we play this season if we give them as much free yardage up the pitch like we did with Fev we are going to struggle. Gannon and Penky are just too hot-headed. Both have been in the game for years now but still give cheap penalties away that put un-necessary pressure on ourselves. Forget about the ref for once. If the players can't control themselves we deserve to have penalties awarded against us.

Fev didn't do too much fancy last night, we're just played it very simple. They didn't give silly penalties away, moved it well from left to right to catch our defence out and kept their cool under pressure.

One other thing, we need to get better distance on our kicks when we have a penalty. One last night looked as if we'd kicked the ball about ten yards.

Sort the ill-disipline out and we have half a chance.

qu)did we get a bonus point last year against Fev,if not Fev have gone backwards this year and we are a point up in compared to last year.

now that's a bloke who's glass is half full!!!

yes it was 26-16 last season to us at the shay, and the year before that you got a bonus point when we beat you 22-20

26-16 would have got us a bonus point and I am sure we didn't get one against you last season

Yes we did.

Button to the right: statistics/championship/sesons/Championship 2010/Halifax RLFC/fixtures

Ive just watched the game back, thought Worrincy played really well. Put the effort in taking the ball forward, made the tackles in the first half and was solid. Sure, not a good effort in the tackle for the try in the corner but time after time he was left 2 on 1 by his own centre which is just poor. He was solid under the kicking game of Fev, just got caught out with one tackle. In all honesty, other than Beswick I thought he was one of Fax's better players.

so a bonus point against fev last year no change and through to the next round of co-op cup,= progress? at this stage of the season.

apologies for senior moment =nrcup.

the TO victory at Fev last season was a cracker - irrespective of the scoreline,if only all RL games could be that entertaining ???

If the in-goal area had been two inches bigger, this thread might have had a completely different feel to it. This was right in front of me, and my first reaction was "try". If not on Sky, I think it would probably have been given. Winning at half-time, and then scoring first in the second may have resulted in a completely different outcome. Sport's a fickle old thing - that's why we love it so much!

'IF' is a big word.............

You're right, and it clearly wasn't a try. Games like this can be settled by the smallest of margins.