Seriously , I wouldn't go for Noble , for me Ryan Sheridan would be OK , but would he come , that is the Question ?Again I think your Squad of players are not that Strong in depth , it happened at Leigh last season , but again with the exception of Leigh , there is not much between the rest of the Clubs in this League , I think the Seagulls are very thin on players , for me the Bullfrogs have gone , Dews are overated ,Fev not that special , and Donny again don't have a big Squad , you are still in the mix , but must start to win , I think you have a few away games on the trot now and must win them , its still there to play for .Charlie knows .

I`m not commenting on wether Karl should go or stay as I don`t think it`s my call but if he was to go I might be inclined to ask Dunaman if he`d fancy it.

Wasn't it rumoured that Dunemann applied when Karl got the job?? He's got a cushty number being a video ref in the NRL

That would ironic if KH lost his job to an aussie !

John Pendlebury

Barry Eaton

Dunneman would be the best option all around. There was a lot of talk of him getting the full-time Canberra head coaching job last year after he did such a good job as caretaker.

Eaton has just extended his deal at Hunslet and really I wouldnt want him. Dunnemann is employed by the NRL as well as having his own business in Australia and doubt he would come.
I would hope the club would look and advertize in Australasia as well as Europe and maybe ask people like Michael Hagan (Queensland Assistant Coach) or Brian Noble for help in finding the right person for the job. I feel Karl was a bad choice and was based on sentiment rather than him being the best person. I think I am right in saying Karl is contracted until the ned of the season. The club really needs to start looking now in my opinion for a new coach rather than at the end of the season. Be honest with Karl and say Thanks but you simply have not met our expectations as there is noway he should have his contract extended

When Matt Calland was coach I attended an open evening where Karl then Batley Manager was one of the guest speakers. Someone asked him if he would like to coach Fax. His courteous response was "you have a coach, but one day, yes I would"
We have a coach now so why not extend that same courtesy until the post is vacant.
I'm not into this "I'm not going until he is gone" surely the club need the revenue to strengthen the team. Stay away and the money is not there to strengthen the squad IF a new coach is appointed.
We even have on another thread "I didn't go" but then he goes on to say what was wrong yesterday.
One bloke behind me said the players aren't fit, this coming from a bloke who looks like he couldn't lift a pencil.
Then this was followed up by another suggesting some players were more interested in Faxfit.
Boll2cks,
Come on, yes the wheels have fallen off, but they can be put back on very quickly, one thing for sure Fax still need OUR support.
I await
But hey, that's life.

So your the perfect person to judge?
You listen to others and judge?
Haven't seen a game for two months, haven't seen you moderating for longer than that.
Hang up yer boots.

KH brought a number of new players in this season so some money must have been available. Brown has been moved on to Batley for some unknown reason when we were short of halves, other players keep getting dropped and we don't seem to have a stable starting lineup.
KH seems to fallout with players, Rettie has not been one of my favourites as a winger but last season was always in but this year can't seem to get a start. We
Lost Worrincey but have had to go and get Saxton on loan so does n't say much about the other players KH brought in.
Just seems to be a lack of a long term plan and any real cohesion week to week so how the players are going to gel is difficult to see.

Take over your contribution of nothing?