Said Tamghart

is ok , he was knocked out,came round ok, enough to be driven home

cool! Just concerned he wasn't moving his legs!

Glad he's sorted - all that matters really!

Misses Thursdays game then? He wasnt driving on his own was he?

what about Shad looked to be limping heavily at the end of the game,any news.

I heard his leg dropped off but the physio managed to strap it back on

Even if Said passes the 'head test' I'd still have Cherryholme over him, I'd have had Cherryholme over Said on Thursday in all honesty.

Although poor on Thursday Said is far superior to Cherryholme.

I feel that Cherryholme is underated

Cherryholme is nowhere near as good as said at going forward, He comes up with too many errors and drops to the floor too easy, Although, saying that, Tamghard is a French Circus Juggler who knocks on a lot.

Have to agree. When Said does get into the game he can cause some real damage, we need to be taking these risks at this point in the season. Him and Makali coming off the bench won't half destroy some defenses, now that Maka is hopefully finding his old ways aswell. Cherryholme reminds me alot of John Simpson, big guy but just falls at the first impact, he's shown on occassions that he can do damage, but it is very rare we see it.

Said made at least two errors which led to Fev tries. Granted Cherryholme isn't as destructive or flash going forward but he tackles his blood to water and always breaks the advantage line and I'd rather have that sort of player at this time of year than one who rushes out of the line leaving the defence vulnerable, tries the impossible miracle ball but most importantly just is not match fit.

Did you read something in my post that i didn't ?. all you have done is confirm what i said. I didn't mention tackling i said Cherryholme is nowhere near as good going forward and as soon as he is hit goes straight down. I also said Said knocks on all the time, so thanks for confirming what i already thought.

Disagree with your Cherryholme breaks the advantage line comment but agree he is maybe a bit more solid rather then spectacular then Said, so do we go for impact which Said can maybe offer but risk mistakes or Cherryholmes steady approach but we give up some explosiveness.