Yes but he scores 2 and lets in 3 or makes 3 silly schoolboy errors, even watching in the final he made some simple errors like not playing the ball right or losing posession easily, v fev he made a few simple errors that put pressure on fax.

Im aware he is good in attack when he wants to be and cutting out those silly errors he makes every game will make him a welcome addition to any team.

most players in the fax team make those liitle silly errors every now and then, not just Rob.

No they don't. Theres a reason he gets pushed infield on the 5th tackle and Haley goes on the wing. Potential is there yes but so were plenty of errors that took the shine off it.

For me he is very inconsistant. Great going forward-though maybe a bit more self confidence would be good and back himself to beat people with his speed and strength.
The negatives are he is not good under a highball or low kick-He is rather clumsy. He is a weakness in the defence due to this. His tackling could and should be better. A big guy like that should be knocking the feck out of his usually smaller wingman-instead he tries grabbing with his hands-and misses. The coaching staff have to work with Rob on them areas for me.
I am still not sure with Rob as you cant fault his effort, but for me 2010 he has to be alot more consistant and work on his problem areas.

YOU MEAN LIKE HIS LAST 4 GAMES!

as for other players making errors; Penky, Said even blacky make their fare share as well.

i agree with u '87

i doubted rob for the 1st half of the season but he proved me wrong near the end... every player in this squad have made mistakes... unfortunatley for rob he was under the hawk eye with bein a new signing and the reputation he has with his speed...

I say cut him sum slack and let him play his game

Whats with the bold font?

What do you mean cut him some slack! Jeez nobody is saying he's ter then brimah kebbie, do you want me to say ok yes i agree finished article, great player, can I have his tie ups please.

He has potential yes, he also makes far too many mistakes to be classed as the finished article, Matt can see this.

Im sure Rob knows this aspect of his game needs work on, none of us need to give him some slack its a case of pointing out blatently obvious aspects of his game that he needs to improve to become a very good winger.

i just prefer t write in bold font...

all im sayin is fax fans (both on and off RLfans) are very fast to point out Robs mistakes and treat him like he is just there to make up numbers. i agree he isnt a finished player yet but for that reason people are like lightening to put him down

its not nice people pointing out his mistakes for the sake of it

To have a proper view look over a whole season. Why just focus on 4 games-in which he did make a number of mistakes which to be fair he should be better with. I am not saying he is crap or not good enough. I am saying he still has a lot to work on especially in defence and catching-and he knows that. He will never be a great player in the mould of Mark Preston or John Bentley but he can become a cult figure like Wilf George.

he's not the finished article, thats obvious.

If he was he wouldn't be playing in the championship.

my point is, when taking his recent form into account he's not a flawed as some people think.

Why, do you assume once he is the finished article he will be in super league! Maybe his potential if he reaches it is a good championship player and he goe son to have a good career in this division, bit presumetious to say if a finished article he will be in super league, im sure he and all of us would love to see that, especially with fax but potential is nothing unless realised.

Nobody is pointing out his mistakes just for the sake of it, otherwise how is he going to improve his game if nobdy ever dare mention is weaker areas for fear of upsetting him or someone on here.

Nobody is going to just do what you want and only big up players even if they have obvious areas that need work on. Are we not allowed to criticize on here now infact I wouldnt even call it criticizing, and lets be fair, its not exactly harsh or putting him down, if you read my posts you will see myself and other saying yes great potential but needs work, why cant you accept that rather then say we are putting him down, cut him some slack, nobody is exactly slagging him off unless your the most sensitive person in the world.

thats more of a fare assesment.

I am all for 'construtive' criticism.

You are kidding me right with that comment, please tell me your secretly giggling at your desk right now?

So we can say he needs work but NOT what aspects of work, lol I give up on here.

Bentley and Preston both made plenty of errors and had several faults in their game, If Rob scored 20+ trys a season Im sure many wouldn't dare say a word against him.

you really need a