'Bout 3 or 4 years ago I thought Hicks was terrible. Well, even last year he gave that Harris try at Fev as vid ref which never was. But I have noticed him get visibly better over time. And he had a great match tonight, one or 2 slightly wrong calls, but the same for both sides.

Thought he was ok... But i welcome "ok" with open arms these days.

I thought Hicks was good tonight. He let the game flow. Lets hope Ronnie "look at me" laughton was watching.
Far better game to watch this week.

Had a really good first half I thought. About midway through the second he did look like losing control a little with a lot of face planting of Fax players going overlooked, started to look like it might kick off a bit. But beyond that, a pretty solid game. And allowed more flowing rugby that I'm expecting will get by at the weekend.

He held his nerve against the whinging scouse crowd. Shouting for forward passes on every fax pass, and for offsides at every Widnes play the ball!

Did you read what they put about her though? Absolutely hilarious. Putting a picture of her in, then putting that it looks normal untill you look closely. Is she really that ugly that you can't actually tell if it's a man or a woman at first then?

Brilliant reporting as ever.

Well nice to see that Ronnie was his usual crap inept pathetic self today How he gets away with the things he does or doesnt is a complete mystery.

Asd for the female touch judge, if you cant keep up with play to give a very clear forward pass inthe first few mins when Hunslet scored... well please stay away & take the *#$% Laughton with you!!!!!!

she can come back for me.
Enjoyed looking at her more than watching some of the rugby today

There was more than 1 forward pass that let to a score, however we were rubbish, full stop. Ronnie needs to grow a pair and hand out some cards if that's the cut of his jib instead trying to decimate his pea every 30 seconds.

I dont know why we even bother having Ronnie as a ref. For every decision he looks at the linesperson(?)

Extract from lawsEnforce Laws
2. The Referees shall enforce the Laws of the Game and may impose penalties for any deliberate breach of the Laws. He shall be the sole judge on matters of fact except those relating to touch and touch in-goal (see para. 11 below).

[iConsult Touch Judge 2. Before giving a decision, it is permissible for the Referee to consult either or both Touch Judges.[/i

IMO, Nat maybe thinking that Rockin' Ronnie couldn't give a decision on his own.

You obviously didn't see Chapman getting sent off then? Other refs would have tinned out on that one, good on Robot on that one.

Personally I don't think he had that bad a game yesterday. He did miss stuff, granted, but EVERY ref misses things. We have had him far too often to know what he gives penalties for cheaply and we still got ourselves into those positions, showed how poor we were IMO. We are too quick to blame the ref for our own ineptitude.

the penalty count was 11-5 in favour of halifax yesterday

The penatly count was so high because of the laurel and hardy performace from the March Brothers, both were playing dirty tactics, it was clear to see they still have a rugby brain, however they were intetent on playing dirty yesterday! and guess what it paid off!