Thats how it works even the best players make mistakes and get punished accordingly.

Hmmm, don't think "mistake" is an apt word in this case. He knew exactly what he was doing ( and in all honesty he did a bloody good job of it )
I hope this tit for tat stops before we meet again, both teams can play hard and both teams can play rugby, nothing wrong with that but if it turns out to who's the best fighters I'd rather watch boxing......................now there's an idea Tonks and Acton for charridy.

You do talk e

That from you? That is funny, but then you already knew that because you know what others think.

He's been charged grade E "with intent" now I accept it's only on charge yet but there must be good reason for it. You'ld make a great defence lawyer (maybe not).
I can just imagine your defence,,,,,,,,,Yes M'lud my client did shoot, stab brutally rape and dismember the said woman, but who, hand on heart can say if he deliberately meant to do these things.

It is disgracefull what he did but people are saying it was a mistake ffs. I'll leave it now as Im sure the disciplinary will sort it..................they're mind readers don't you know

And I stand by that, if we all had your blind faith and rosey tint no-one would ever get charged with anything. I don't believe in all that mystic but I saw it close up and in the replays..............he meant it and I don't need to be a mind reader to KNOW that

I'm entitled to post where I want to keeping to the rules. If you can't handle it .................tough

Classic reply by the way..............losing the case, spit dummy out and say your bored. Then tell me to leave the forum. I'll be you took you ball home as a kid when you were losing the game. Classic toys out of the pram stuff

Its a rough tough sport and these things still go on. You would have thought it was the middle of winter with the amount of 'sledging' going on.

Sams a big lad, and he went down like a sack of spuds. It was a shocker, BUT THESE THINGS HAPPEN !!

Leigh are no angels, and both teams had a point to prove. The officials must have a say in this as there should have been at least 4 binnings before this happened. A decent Ref would have dealt with this better.

Manning will get a caning for his 'Les Boyd' type tackle, and it oozes a case of history and retribution. He wasn't gonna miss.

His he Terry Mannings lad ? He was an hard player too but in a fair way. Irrespective, I am sure the halifax board will do what seems fit.

I have resisted to post on this matter but Snowy - you Sir make sense. It has happened folks, let's move on - your bickering won#t make the slightest difference to the ruling.

Sam is a good lad but did go down like a sack of spuds. Dane's "method" was poor and not thought out. Conclusion bad tackle poor outcome.

Move on time.

Well done Leigh on the win. See you at the end of the year (hopefully)

Grade E AND Grade D. Two charges from the same minute of the game.

one for the tackle, one for the following skirmish, whats your point?

Even Big Sam commented on his facebook page its all part of the game. Sam would of been quite happy to of put that tackle in and has done many times before. Leigh fans, if your not happy with the Rugby you saw on Wednesday, please feel free to attend the new touch rugby league in Calderdale. Even girls play it..

Some Leigh fans need to get over it, the majority who are moaning won't have played the game. Tit for tat over 2 games and Sam came off worst. Mannings season could be over as a result with a potential 13 match ban if worst comes to worst, we will deal with that as and when.

I'm proud of the boys, move on, Workington Sunday, 4 of us dining, hope manning is there. Can have a chat, see what he says and cheer on my team.

Up the fax, F"!k the leythers, it's HRLFC that I care about.