I know we are waiting for news on who we are resigning and new signings, which players would we not want to resign for next year ?

Why discuss this when they will probably play for us again this year?

All players apart from Said Tamghart are out of contract, they all signed 1 year contracts last year !

We know, think A.N other was refering to the fact that all the players will stil have a part to play this year and it won't do any good saying who we'd like to get rid of on here.

get most of them signed on including black,penky, glesson, Beswick and franky and patterson infact sign all of them again to new contracts

My thoughts too, we have won nothing yet only matches we have not got to a final yet either.We need to be behind this team 100% never mind talking about who to get rid of.

Yeh fair point

Sorry mate...you have a good point but at this stage of the season its best left alone, we need all the players pulling in the right direction.

We are top of the league.. in the semi final of our domestic cup.. run a full time super league team reet into extra time.... why get rid and not just add to the squad??

penky is way over rated, black was non existent today

We are a strong squad that is doing really well in the league. There are one or two players that are probably worried about their place in the squad for next season (and they should be), but it is up to them to step up to the mark to earn their spot and not up to us to name names and cause unrest in the squad.

At the end of the day, if they are good enough they will be in the squad, if not, then we will move on without them.

You on drugs mate?

Well he must be overrated by virtually all coaches, players and fans of our league then.

no need for this topic in my fantastic opinion, all it could possibly do is damage player morale!

Totally opposite IMO as most people have come on and totaly shat on what was a negative post!!

ellis was the best 9 on the field today for a full 80, Gleeson was class when he came on, penky was woefull, take off your blinkers

I dont have blinkers on - Penky at hooker is the best or 2nd best behind Gleeson in our league - Players can have an off day but he was still one of our better players. I think it may be you that has blinkers on.

wake up dude, penky has been woeful for weeks, beswick is a better hooker, penky is 4th best nowadays

I am wide awake - As good as Beswick is, he isnt as good as Penk at hooker - Penks distribution is quicker, his pace running from actining half is faster, he spots a gap better.

And you only named 2 players - why would he be the 4th best hooker?

gleeson
ellis
beswick
penky

How often have you seen Ellis play this year?

Penky might not have had his best game but he is a game winner I.e Fev away.. Just wish he kept hold of ball more.. He is far more effective as a dummy half runner than a ball handler

4

maybe thats the problem hes been played at 6 when he isn't

You have an indepth knowledge of his game then. If you think he is better than penky then im glad you dont have anything to do with recruitment at Fax. He had a good game today yes - scored three tries and made one good break. Doesnt mean that he is better than Penky.