Quote: Kelvin's Ferret "There is a very solid argument that the British Empire was effectively the English Empire, and that it began to develop from the Age of Discovery, in England's case with John Cabot…'"
A Venetian – which adds to your point.
In similar vein, Henry VIII had to bring in French expertise on cannon production to give us the weaponary that would build the Navy.
Quote: Kelvin's Ferret "… The interesting point is that this expansion began under the Tudors, a Welsh dynasty that ruled England, followed by a Scottish dynasty, the Stuarts, followed by a series of German and Dutch houses that we have retained right up to this day (albeit now as ceremonial figureheads rather than absolute rulers). Leading to the claim that Richard III was the last "English" ruler of England (I'm not entirely convinced about this claim given 1) the Plantagenets were a branch of the House of Anjou and 2) such distinctions belong to a era before the modern nation state emerged).'"
All correct – and yes, it is all interesting, not least perhaps, in terms of how few people either realise or acknowledge such things.
Quote: Kelvin's Ferret "I think it's the relative size of England in terms of territory, population and economic strength that is the underlying issue, England's population is several times larger than the rest of the British Isles (ROI included) put together. In the face of that it was more important to the rest to not be absorbed into an overarching English identity than it was for England itself to maintain an English identity. Having said that I do think some of the modern national identity politics of the island of Great Britain have more than a whiff of Victorian romanticism about them, as do modern "Celtic" identity contructs throughout the whole of the British Isles.'"
I’d agree with all that. I’d add that the issue of size and population is also one that, I think, influences feelings about immigration/migration.
We are incredibly densely populated.
The UK is 256 people per square km.
England, though, is 419 people per square km. In a list of countries and dependencies in Europe, that only has Monaco, Gibraltar, Vatican City, Malta, Guernsey, Jersey and San Marino ahead of it.
Germany is 233, Italy 192 and France 111, Spain 88. Sweden is just 20.
Looked at another way
Fair points all: I don’t think we’re actually disagreeing. Perhaps I could have been clearer: I think we make the mistake of still trying to play the superpower role – most often and most obviously in terms of our relationship with the US and military action.